OnlyLocal
Verified Independent

Carmel Creek Plumbing

Owned and operated by Patrick Reinhardt

Carmel, INplumbing2-10 People
4.2(17 reviews)

About

Hello — I'm Patrick, founder of Carmel Creek Plumbing. We've been quietly building a reputation around Hamilton County for 15 years. I personally walk every job before we start so the homeowner knows exactly what to expect. Our work is backed by a real warranty in writing, not a verbal handshake. If you've ever felt rushed or upsold by a contractor, you'll notice the difference right away. Demo listing

Years in business
15
Team size
5-10
Primary service area
Carmel, IN

Services

Tankless water heater installsToilet installationLeak detectionWater softener installationFaucet & fixture repairGas line repairSewer line repair

Service area

ZIP codes served:

  • 46032
  • 46033

Reviews

4.2
17 reviews
5
9
4
3
3
4
2
1
1
0
H

Holly A.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

We're customers for life now. Patrick and they replaced our 22-year-old water heater on a Saturday morning.

S

Steve H.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Not bad but not great either. Patrick and the team ran a new line to our outdoor kitchen and added a frost-free hose bib.

S

Steve H.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Best decision we made all year. Patrick installed a tankless unit and reworked the gas line in one day, and the whole crew made sure our dog was comfortable around the crew. They also called the night before to confirm, which we really appreciated. We've already recommended Patrick to two neighbors.

T

Tom C.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Could not ask for better. Patrick ran a new line to our outdoor kitchen and added a frost-free hose bib, and the whole crew wore booties in the house without being asked. They also took the time to answer every question we had, which we really appreciated. Will be using them for everything from now on.

P

Pat M.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Started strong and faded. Patrick ran a new line to our outdoor kitchen and added a frost-free hose bib, and the whole crew explained everything in plain English without talking down to us. They also had a clearly labeled truck and uniformed crew, which we really appreciated. We'd think twice before calling them again.

S

Sarah R.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Really pleased with the result. Patrick rebuilt the half-bath from the rough-in up after we bought the house, and the whole crew called the night before to confirm. They also made sure our dog was comfortable around the crew, which we really appreciated. Highly recommend with one minor caveat — but no big deal.

D

Drew H.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Couldn't be happier with how this turned out. Patrick and they replaced our 22-year-old water heater on a Saturday morning.

K

Kelly B.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Great experience with one tiny nitpick. Patrick and they installed a tankless unit and reworked the gas line in one day.

T

Trent G.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Best decision we made all year. Patrick and they rebuilt the half-bath from the rough-in up after we bought the house.

H

Hank W.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Could not ask for better. Patrick and they replaced our sump pump the night before a big storm rolled in.

R

Ryan S.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Phenomenal. Patrick replaced our 22-year-old water heater on a Saturday morning, and the whole crew stuck to the original quote with no surprise add-ons. They also explained everything in plain English without talking down to us, which we really appreciated. Will be using them for everything from now on.

M

Mark K.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Hands down the easiest home-service decision we've made. Patrick and they replaced our 22-year-old water heater on a Saturday morning, and they called the night before to confirm. Ten out of ten — this is how it should be.

B

Bill E.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

It was okay — got the job done. Patrick and the team replaced our 22-year-old water heater on a Saturday morning, and they explained everything in plain English without talking down to us. Fine for a basic job, not sure for anything complex.

C

Cindy S.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Really pleased with the result. Patrick and they installed a tankless unit and reworked the gas line in one day, and they stuck to the original quote with no surprise add-ons. Highly recommend with one minor caveat — but no big deal.

M

Matt W.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Job is finished and works fine, just not blown away. Patrick and the team replaced our sump pump the night before a big storm rolled in, and they explained everything in plain English without talking down to us. Fine for a basic job, not sure for anything complex.

K

Karl F.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Honestly, exceeded our expectations. Patrick and they installed a tankless unit and reworked the gas line in one day, and they took the time to answer every question we had. We've already recommended Patrick to two neighbors.

C

Cory O.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Not bad but not great either. Patrick and the team replaced our sump pump the night before a big storm rolled in, and they wore booties in the house without being asked. Fine for a basic job, not sure for anything complex.