OnlyLocal
Verified Independent

Hamilton Heights Painting

Owned and operated by Rachel Yoder

Carmel, INpainting11-50 People
4.7(14 reviews)

About

Hello — I'm Rachel, founder of Hamilton Heights Painting. We've been quietly building a reputation around Hamilton County for 18 years. We specialize in residential work — no commercial, no shortcuts. Most of my crew has been with me for over five years, which is rare in this trade. If you've ever felt rushed or upsold by a contractor, you'll notice the difference right away. Demo listing

Years in business
18
Team size
26-50
Primary service area
Carmel, IN

Services

Deck staining & sealingWallpaper removalPower washingColor consultationDrywall repair

Service area

ZIP codes served:

  • 46032
  • 46033

Reviews

4.7
14 reviews
5
10
4
4
3
0
2
0
1
0
C

Christine H.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Could not ask for better. Rachel and they painted all the trim and doors throughout — sharper edges than I knew were possible.

T

Tyler H.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Absolutely the best experience we've had with a contractor. Rachel and they removed three layers of wallpaper from a bathroom and you'd never know it was there.

D

Dan F.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Solid work overall, would use again. Rachel and they removed three layers of wallpaper from a bathroom and you'd never know it was there.

T

Tim M.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Genuinely good work and good people. Rachel and they stained our deck and wrapped the spindles individually — incredible attention to detail, and they stuck to the original quote with no surprise add-ons. Glad we picked them.

T

Theo P.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

We are so glad we found Rachel and the team. Rachel and they painted the entire main floor in three days with zero mess.

L

Linda R.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Could not ask for better. Rachel and they did the exterior of our two-story Victorian and the prep work alone was a master class, and they had a clearly labeled truck and uniformed crew. If you're on the fence, just call them.

A

Austin P.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Honestly, exceeded our expectations. Rachel and they refinished our oak cabinets and they look like new shaker boxes, and they had a clearly labeled truck and uniformed crew. Saved their number to favorites.

L

Laura H.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Hands down the easiest home-service decision we've made. Rachel and they refinished our oak cabinets and they look like new shaker boxes, and they wore booties in the house without being asked. Saved their number to favorites.

D

Diana K.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Could not ask for better. Rachel and they did the exterior of our two-story Victorian and the prep work alone was a master class, and they showed up exactly when they said they would. Will be using them for everything from now on.

H

Holly M.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Best decision we made all year. Rachel and they stained our deck and wrapped the spindles individually — incredible attention to detail, and they took the time to answer every question we had. We've already recommended Rachel to two neighbors.

W

Wade E.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Truly above and beyond. Rachel and they did the exterior of our two-story Victorian and the prep work alone was a master class, and they left the worksite cleaner than they found it. Will be using them for everything from now on.

L

Lisa N.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Would recommend to friends. Rachel and they color-matched a touch-up perfectly six months after the original job, and they called the night before to confirm. Glad we picked them.

E

Ed H.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Genuinely good work and good people. Rachel and they did the exterior of our two-story Victorian and the prep work alone was a master class.

W

Wayne H.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Truly above and beyond. Rachel and they painted all the trim and doors throughout — sharper edges than I knew were possible.