OnlyLocal
Verified Independent

Mueller Painting Services

Owned and operated by Joel Carey

Carmel, INpainting1 Person
4.3(19 reviews)

About

I'm Joel, owner of Mueller Painting Services. We've served Hamilton County families for 12 years and counting. We specialize in residential work — no commercial, no shortcuts. Our work is backed by a real warranty in writing, not a verbal handshake. Reach out and let's talk about your project. Demo listing

Years in business
12
Team size
1
Primary service area
Carmel, IN

Services

Wallpaper removalColor consultationCabinet refinishingPower washingDeck staining & sealingTrim & door painting

Service area

ZIP codes served:

  • 46032
  • 46033

Reviews

4.3
19 reviews
5
10
4
6
3
1
2
2
1
0
S

Sarah B.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Really pleased with the result. Joel painted all the trim and doors throughout — sharper edges than I knew were possible, and the whole crew picked up after themselves every single day. They also wore booties in the house without being asked, which we really appreciated. Glad we picked them.

D

Dylan A.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Some real issues we had to work through. Joel and the crew did the exterior of our two-story Victorian and the prep work alone was a master class, and they called the night before to confirm. We'd think twice before calling them again.

S

Sarah E.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Five stars all the way. Joel and they did our nursery the weekend before our baby came home.

S

Sarah V.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Could not ask for better. Joel color-matched a touch-up perfectly six months after the original job, and the whole crew picked up after themselves every single day. They also had a clearly labeled truck and uniformed crew, which we really appreciated. If you're on the fence, just call them.

M

Maria H.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Quality work, fair price. Joel and they stained our deck and wrapped the spindles individually — incredible attention to detail.

T

Trevor H.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Just outstanding work from start to finish. Joel and they refinished our oak cabinets and they look like new shaker boxes, and they stuck to the original quote with no surprise add-ons. Ten out of ten — this is how it should be.

S

Stephanie K.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Just outstanding work from start to finish. Joel removed three layers of wallpaper from a bathroom and you'd never know it was there, and the whole crew sent us photos of the progress while we were at work. They also wore booties in the house without being asked, which we really appreciated. Saved their number to favorites.

K

Karl C.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Top-notch in every way. Joel did the exterior of our two-story Victorian and the prep work alone was a master class, and the whole crew explained everything in plain English without talking down to us. They also left the worksite cleaner than they found it, which we really appreciated. Will be using them for everything from now on.

W

Wesley K.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Five stars all the way. Joel and they painted all the trim and doors throughout — sharper edges than I knew were possible, and they sent us photos of the progress while we were at work. Saved their number to favorites.

G

Garrett D.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Came through for us. Joel and they painted all the trim and doors throughout — sharper edges than I knew were possible.

D

Doug W.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Came through for us. Joel and they removed three layers of wallpaper from a bathroom and you'd never know it was there, and they picked up after themselves every single day. Would call them again without hesitation.

B

Beth E.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

We are so glad we found Joel and the team. Joel painted the entire main floor in three days with zero mess, and the whole crew stuck to the original quote with no surprise add-ons. They also had a clearly labeled truck and uniformed crew, which we really appreciated. If you're on the fence, just call them.

M

Mike M.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Not bad but not great either. Joel and the team refinished our oak cabinets and they look like new shaker boxes.

W

Wade W.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Came through for us. Joel and they refinished our oak cabinets and they look like new shaker boxes.

D

Drew H.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Disappointing experience honestly. Joel painted all the trim and doors throughout — sharper edges than I knew were possible, and the whole crew explained everything in plain English without talking down to us. They also sent us photos of the progress while we were at work, which we really appreciated. Hopefully our experience was an outlier.

G

Gina M.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Phenomenal. Joel refinished our oak cabinets and they look like new shaker boxes, and the whole crew made sure our dog was comfortable around the crew. They also called the night before to confirm, which we really appreciated. Saved their number to favorites.

L

Laura O.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Very happy with the job. Joel and they removed three layers of wallpaper from a bathroom and you'd never know it was there.

K

Kim S.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Couldn't be happier with how this turned out. Joel and they refinished our oak cabinets and they look like new shaker boxes, and they explained everything in plain English without talking down to us. Ten out of ten — this is how it should be.

C

Cory L.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

We're customers for life now. Joel and they stained our deck and wrapped the spindles individually — incredible attention to detail.