OnlyLocal
Verified Independent

Old Town Carmel Plumbing

Owned and operated by Eric Lehman

Carmel, INplumbing11-50 People
4.4(18 reviews)

About

Hello — I'm Eric, founder of Old Town Carmel Plumbing. We've been quietly building a reputation around Hamilton County for 19 years. We specialize in residential work — no commercial, no shortcuts. I served in the Navy before getting into the trades, and that discipline shows up in our jobsite cleanliness. Quotes are free and there's never any pressure. Demo listing

Years in business
19
Team size
26-50
Primary service area
Carmel, IN

Services

Faucet & fixture repairWater softener installationWater heater installationSump pump replacementDrain cleaning & hydro-jettingGarbage disposal installTankless water heater installs

Service area

ZIP codes served:

  • 46032
  • 46033

Reviews

4.4
18 reviews
5
12
4
3
3
2
2
0
1
1
K

Karen K.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Genuinely good work and good people. Eric and they swapped out three corroded shutoffs we'd been ignoring for years, and they showed up exactly when they said they would. Would call them again without hesitation.

P

Pat S.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Absolutely the best experience we've had with a contractor. Eric and they installed a tankless unit and reworked the gas line in one day, and they made sure our dog was comfortable around the crew. Ten out of ten — this is how it should be.

T

Trevor A.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Wow — what a refreshing experience. Eric and they rebuilt the half-bath from the rough-in up after we bought the house.

S

Stephanie N.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Got what we paid for. Eric and the team fixed a hidden leak above the kitchen ceiling without tearing up the drywall, and they made sure our dog was comfortable around the crew. We'd probably try them again, but get a couple other quotes first.

A

Allison E.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Genuinely good work and good people. Eric rebuilt the half-bath from the rough-in up after we bought the house, and the whole crew sent us photos of the progress while we were at work. They also took the time to answer every question we had, which we really appreciated. Would call them again without hesitation.

T

Tara E.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Truly above and beyond. Eric and they tracked down a slab leak two other plumbers told us was a foundation issue.

A

Allison D.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Phenomenal. Eric and they installed a tankless unit and reworked the gas line in one day.

F

Frank H.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Phenomenal. Eric fixed a hidden leak above the kitchen ceiling without tearing up the drywall, and the whole crew left the worksite cleaner than they found it. They also offered three different options at three different price points, which we really appreciated. We've already recommended Eric to two neighbors.

J

Jessica F.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Mostly a positive experience with some hiccups. Eric and the team ran a new line to our outdoor kitchen and added a frost-free hose bib.

H

Holly O.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

These folks are the real deal. Eric and they replaced our sump pump the night before a big storm rolled in.

C

Cameron C.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Wow — what a refreshing experience. Eric and they rebuilt the half-bath from the rough-in up after we bought the house.

E

Ethan B.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

These folks are the real deal. Eric and they fixed a hidden leak above the kitchen ceiling without tearing up the drywall.

A

Amanda F.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Top-notch in every way. Eric and they swapped out three corroded shutoffs we'd been ignoring for years, and they offered three different options at three different price points. If you're on the fence, just call them.

C

Christine C.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Couldn't be happier with how this turned out. Eric and they replaced our 22-year-old water heater on a Saturday morning, and they wore booties in the house without being asked. If you're on the fence, just call them.

K

Karl P.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Dependable and easy to work with. Eric and they rebuilt the half-bath from the rough-in up after we bought the house, and they sent us photos of the progress while we were at work. Highly recommend with one minor caveat — but no big deal.

C

Connor H.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Pretty frustrating from start to finish. Eric and the crew tracked down a slab leak two other plumbers told us was a foundation issue, and they called the night before to confirm. Hard pass.

C

Carol P.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

Truly above and beyond. Eric replaced our 22-year-old water heater on a Saturday morning, and the whole crew had a clearly labeled truck and uniformed crew. They also called the night before to confirm, which we really appreciated. Saved their number to favorites.

H

Hunter A.

May 2, 2026

Verified customer

We are so glad we found Eric and the team. Eric rebuilt the half-bath from the rough-in up after we bought the house, and the whole crew made sure our dog was comfortable around the crew. They also sent us photos of the progress while we were at work, which we really appreciated. Ten out of ten — this is how it should be.